top of page


The Overseas Highway in Islamorada and the Florida Keys, while enchanting, is not immune to the risks of motor vehicle accidents. Recent data from the Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Department highlights a concerning trend in Monroe County, with an increasing number of accidents leading to injuries and fatalities. In Islamorada, Marathon, Key West and all the other Florida Keys, these incidents often stem from various causes, including distracted driving — a growing issue linked to smartphone usage and in-car technology distractions. Beyond this, factors like speeding, weather conditions, and impaired driving contribute to the accident rate.


At The Sheldrick Law Firm, we are devoted to navigating the complexities of personal injury claims in Islamorada along with up and down all of the Florida Keys. Our focus is on providing thorough legal support to those affected by such accidents, ensuring they understand and can effectively pursue their rights under Florida law.

Dedicated Legal Advocacy for Accident Victims in Islamorada and the Florida Keys

At The Sheldrick Law Firm, we offer comprehensive legal services to the residents and visitors of Islamorada and the Florida Keys. Confronting the aftermath of a car crash, a moped mishap, or a boating accident requires knowledgeable legal support, and our team is prepared to provide just that. We're well-versed in the unique challenges of accidents in the Florida Keys, from Key West slip and falls to Islamorada boating accident injuries. Our commitment is to pursue fair compensation for your injuries, tackling cases from motorcycle accidents on the picturesque Overseas Highway to scooter accidents in Key West's vibrant locales. For those who are in the Florida Keys and seeking a car accident attorney who handles injury cases, The Sheldrick Law Firm is ready to assertively defend your rights with commitment and focus.

Do You Need Legal Help with No-Fault Car Accident Claims in Islamorada, Marathon, or any other of the Florida Keys?


Understanding PIP Coverage

Essentials of Personal Injury Protection (PIP) in the Florida Keys:

In the Florida Keys, including Islamorada, Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is a critical component of auto accident claims. This no-fault insurance covers up to 80% of medical costs and 60% of lost wages, usually up to $10,000. However, if medical treatment isn't sought within 14 days for an emergency condition, this cap may be reduced to as low as $2,500.

Limitations of PIP in Serious Injury Cases:

  • PIP is generally sufficient for minor injuries but may fall short in more severe cases, potentially leaving significant medical and other expenses uncovered.

  • In such instances, it may be necessary to seek additional compensation from the at-fault party, especially if injuries are serious, involving significant and permanent impairment or disfigurement.

The Role of a Lawyer in Complex Injury Claims:

  • In serious injury claims where PIP is insufficient, proving the extent of injuries and the other party’s negligence is crucial. This is where the expertise of an Islamorada personal injury attorney becomes invaluable.

  • An attorney can advocate for comprehensive compensation that goes beyond PIP, addressing all your medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering.

Defining Negligence in Islamorada and Florida Keys Car Accidents:

  • Common examples of negligence in car accidents include careless driving, speeding, and failure to yield. Establishing such negligence is critical for pursuing additional compensation in cases where PIP coverage is inadequate.

Islamorada Car Accident Lawyer
Scooter accident and injury lawyer serving Islamorada and all of the Florida Keys
Islamorada Bicycle Accident Lawyer
Islamorada Pedestrian Accident and Personal Injury Lawyer
Motorcycle accident lawyer in the Florida Keys.
Uber Accident Lawyer in the Florida Keys
Slip and Fall Lawyer in Florida Keys
Truck Accident Lawyer in Florida Keys
Key West train accident lawyer.


Input your accident details so that we can have our attorney who handles matters in the Florida Keys evaluate your claim & be in contact with you.

Thanks for submitting!

Palm Trees
Islamorada Florida Keys car accident and personal injury lawyer Kayla Sheldrick.

Seeking a Personal Injury Lawyer
in Islamorada or the Florida Keys?

Islamorada Accident And Personal Injury Lawyer Kayla Sheldrick

Have you or a loved one been involved in an accident in Islamorada or the Florida Keys?

Don’t navigate this challenging time alone. Attorney Kayla Sheldrick is here to offer you personalized, compassionate legal assistance. With an understanding of Florida's personal injury laws and a commitment to advocating for your rights, Ms. Sheldrick will guide you through the intricacies of your case and work diligently towards the best possible outcome. Reach out today for a free consultation, and take the first step towards peace of mind and justice. 





Jet Skiing in the Florida Keys Alligator reef lighthouse_


After a car accident in Islamorada, ensure your safety and that of others, call 911, and seek medical attention if needed. Document the scene with photos and gather contact information from witnesses and the other driver. It's also important to report the accident to your insurance company without admitting fault, and consider consulting with a personal injury lawyer to understand your rights and options.

What Should I Do After a Car Accident in Islamorada, Florida Keys.

Look for a lawyer with experience in handling car accident cases in the Florida Keys. Check their track record, client testimonials, and their expertise in Florida's specific traffic and personal injury laws. A consultation can help determine if they understand your needs and can offer the right representation.

How Do I Choose the Right Personal Injury Lawyer in Islamorada.

Yes, you can claim compensation for a boating accident in the Florida Keys, especially if it resulted from someone else's negligence. Start by reporting the accident to the Coast Guard or local authorities, documenting the scene, and seeking medical care. Then, contact a personal injury lawyer experienced in boating accidents in the Florida Keys to guide you through the compensation claim process.

Can I Claim Compensation for a Boating Accident in the Florida Keys
bottom of page