top of page
The Sheldrick Law Firm's blog that posts informative information for readers to learn from and help better our readers awareness.
  • Facebook badge for The Sheldrick Law Firm
  • Instagram badge for The Sheldrick Law Firm
  • Twitter badge for The Sheldrick Law Firm
  • Tumblr badge for The Sheldrick Law Firm

Filing Diminished Value Claims in Florida, New Jersey, and New York

File a diminished value claim in Florida, New Jersey, and New York.

Imagine you've been involved in a car accident in a hustle and bustle city like New York, crashing on the Garden State Parkway in New Jersey or a quiet suburb in Florida. Your vehicle, once repaired, seems as good as new, but there's an invisible scar - a diminished market value. This drop in value is an often-overlooked consequence of auto accidents affecting drivers across various states, including Florida, New Jersey, and New York. Diminished value claims provide a path to recoup this loss, becoming an essential consideration for affected vehicle owners.

Florida's Approach to Diminished Value Claims:

In the evolving legal landscape of Florida, the recent tort reform law, effective March 24, 2023, has significant implications for diminished value claims. The statute of limitations, previously set at four years is now down to two years, impacting car owners' claims for compensation after accidents.

Filing a diminished value claim in Florida requires detailed documentation of the vehicle's damage. This includes a comprehensive report and record of damaged parts and repairs, crucial for substantiating the claim for the vehicle’s loss in market value post-accident.

With these legal shifts, staying informed and consulting with a seasoned diminished value lawyer familiar with Florida's car accident laws and diminished value claims becomes crucial for claimants. For updated legal information, Florida's official legislative resources are recommended.

Here are a few Frequently Asked Questions and Answers about Florida Diminished Value Claims

FAQ 1: Are Detailed Documentation and Appraisals Required for Florida Diminished Value Claims?

  • Question: What kind of documentation do I need to support a diminished value claim in Florida?

  • Answer: Yes, detailed documentation is essential for a successful diminished value claim in Florida. This includes comprehensive records of the vehicle's pre-accident condition, the extent of damages, repair invoices, and an appraisal report to establish the diminished value. Proper documentation bolsters your claim, helping to accurately assess the loss in your vehicle’s value.

FAQ 2: Filing Time Frame for Diminished Value Claims in Florida

  • Question: What is the statute of limitations for filing a diminished value claim in Florida

  • Answer: In Florida, as of March 24, 2023, the statute of limitations for filing a diminished value claim is two years from the date of the accident. This means you have two years to file your claim to recoup the lost value of your vehicle post-collision.



Diminished Value Claim Form




New Jersey's approach to Diminished Value Claims

In New Jersey, the legal statutes for diminished value claims is uniquely accommodating, especially when compared to many other states. New Jersey law not only recognizes the right to claim diminished value in third-party claims but also extends this right to certain first-party claims. This is particularly significant in scenarios where the at-fault driver is uninsured or underinsured.

In the event of an accident caused by an underinsured or uninsured driver, policyholders in New Jersey with specific coverage – commonly known as "Property Damage Under/Uninsured Motorists Coverage" – can file a first-party diminished value claim against their own insurance. This provision is a notable exception in the United States, where the majority of states do not allow policyholders to pursue diminished value claims against their own insurance in such situations.


The statute of limitations for filing a diminished value claim in New Jersey is six years.

This time frame gives vehicle owners ample opportunity to assess the diminished value and pursue a claim. The measure of damages in these claims is determined by the difference in the vehicle’s value immediately before and after the accident. This assessment is crucial and is backed by legal precedents set in cases like Jones v. Lahn and Financial Services Vehicle Trust v. Panter.

Understanding these nuances of New Jersey's laws on diminished value claims is vital for drivers, particularly in the densely populated areas around Toms River, Brick Town, Point Pleasant, Red Bank, Holmdel, Middletown, and others. The Sheldrick Law Firm can assist car accident victims in navigating these complex claims, ensuring they understand their rights and options, especially in the unique context of first-party diminished value claims in New Jersey.

Legal Insights: Diminished Value Claims in New Jersey - Frequently Asked Questions

FAQ 1: Finding a Diminished Value Claim Lawyer in New Jersey

  • Question: How do I find a reputable lawyer for a diminished value claim in New Jersey?

  • Answer: To find a reputable diminished value claim lawyer in New Jersey, you can start by researching law firms that specialize in auto accident and property damage claims. Look for attorneys with a strong track record in handling similar cases and check for client testimonials and reviews. The Sheldrick Law Firm, known for its devotion in Diminished Value and Loss Of Claims, is a reliable choice for legal representation in New Jersey.

FAQ 2: Role of a Lawyer in Diminished Value Claims in New Jersey

  • Question: What is the role of a lawyer in a diminished value claim in New Jersey?

  • Answer: In New Jersey, a lawyer specializing in diminished value claims plays a crucial role in accurately assessing the loss in value of your vehicle post-accident, negotiating with insurance companies, and ensuring that all legal procedures are correctly followed. They can provide expert guidance on the documentation required and represent your interests to secure the best possible outcome for your claim.





New York's approach to diminished value claims



Navigating the realm of "New York diminished value claims" can be intricate and daunting. In New York, when a vehicle is involved in an accident, its resale value often depreciates, a phenomenon known as "vehicle depreciation after accidents." This article aims to elucidate the complexities of diminished value claims in New York, providing a comprehensive overview for those seeking "diminished value compensation in NY."

Understanding Diminished Value in New York

Diminished value refers to the reduction in a vehicle's market value following an auto accident, irrespective of repairs. In New York, this concept is critical for vehicle owners, as it impacts the "auto accident resale value loss."

New York statute of limitations for property damage claims is 3 years.

Statute of Limitations and Claim Types

In New York, it's imperative to file diminished value claims within a three-year window post-accident. The state recognizes third-party diminished value claims, although these can be challenging due to conflicting court rulings. First-party claims, conversely, are generally not supported as most insurance policies exclude diminished value.

Legal Framework and Case Law

The legal landscape in New York for diminished value claims is intricate. While there's no strong precedent specifically for diminished value compensation, cases like Franklin Corp v. Prahler highlight the court's recognition that a plaintiff should be made whole. Being "made whole" entails the accident victim to be back to the same financial state prior to the detriment of the accident occurring.

Filing a Claim

Getting a report to file a diminished value claim in New York
Diminished Value Claim Report

"Filing diminished value claims in New York" involves proving the loss through an independent appraisal, followed by submitting this appraisal alongside a demand letter to the at-fault party's insurance company. The claim settlement process can be challenging, often requiring negotiations or legal action.

Challenges and Calculating Value

Insurers may fully settle, partially settle, or deny these claims, necessitating robust negotiation skills or legal support. Determining the value of a vehicle for a diminished value claim is complex, typically requiring expert auto appraisers' insights.

Types of Diminished Value Claims

There are various types of diminished value claims, each addressing different loss aspects due to vehicle damage: Immediate Diminished Value, Repair Caused Diminished Value, and Inherent Diminished Value. These claims are essential for understanding the extent of value loss post-accident.

Case Law Analysis and Critiques

The New York legal system has been critiqued for its approach to diminished value compensation. The process of determining loss value varies significantly, with multiple dealer opinions often resulting in a fairer assessment.

In summary, navigating diminished value claims in New York requires an understanding of the state's legal nuances, statute of limitations, types of claims, and the process of filing and negotiating these claims. With the potential challenges in claim settlement and the complexity of calculating vehicle value, it's often prudent to seek professional legal advice. This comprehensive guide serves as an essential resource for anyone dealing with "New York diminished value claims," aiming to secure fair "diminished value compensation in NY."


1. How Do I Calculate the Diminished Value of My Car in New York?

  • The calculation involves assessing the car's market value before and after the accident, considering factors like make, model, age, and extent of damages. An independent appraiser often plays a key role in this process.

2. Can I File a Diminished Value Claim in New York If I'm At Fault?

  • In New York, such scenarios are complex, typically depending on the specific terms of the insurance policy and state law nuances.

3. What Are the Common Challenges in Settling Diminished Value Claims in New York?

  • Challenges can include insurance company disputes, proving the extent of value loss, and navigating the legal process, especially in the context of conflicting court rulings in New York.


Client testimonial for diminished value claims, loss of use claims, car accident claims at a 5 star rated accident law firm by google.

Mr. Gomez (Local Guide): I was extremely satisfied with Kayla's services as my attorney. She was very knowledgeable and explained my case to me in a way that I could understand. She also responded to my questions quickly and efficiently. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for legal representation.

Mr. Cordeiro: The Sheldrick Law Group, Is built of an amazing team. I was backed into in a parking lot and Kayla fought for me to get my diminished value claim and loss of use. Definitely would call them again if I needed to lets hope it doesn't come to it!

Ms. Peyser: Kayla is one of the best attorneys I have ever worked with, she is extremely knowledgeable. She took the edge off and handled everything for me down to scheduling all my appointments to fit my schedule. I am extremely happy with my outcome and would highly recommend the Sheldrick Law Firm. Many thanks and grateful for your service. God bless you your family and staff

Mr. Consoul: I had a really tough case that my insurance company wasn’t budging on. After contacting Sheldrick, it was a totally different situation.. they got my insurance company to resolve the case without me having to give up on what I was expecting.. it rare you get a law firm that is just as concerned about the final outcome as you are. Felt like I had a true friend in the fight

J.D. (Local Guide): Very knowledgeable. I previously called about a Diminished in Value inquiry and gave me information needing to move forward with my claim.

Don't allow an insurance company to devalue your claim, consult with a Diminished Value Lawyer here at The Sheldrick Law Firm.



(561) 440-7775




Submit a form and an attorney will be in contact with you shortly after.


bottom of page